How to Break the Habit of Overthinking: Because your brain deserves a break too!

Your brain deserves a break too

Let’s be honest - if overthinking burned calories, we’d all be supermodels by now.

One minute you're thinking about whether to send that email…Next, you're spiraling into "What if they hate me?", "What if I’m not good enough?", and "What if I accidentally become a llama farmer in Peru?"

Sound familiar?

Overthinking is like that annoying friend who talks way too much and never lets you make a decision in peace. It's exhausting, unproductive, and often sneaks in dressed as “being prepared” or “just thinking things through.”

But here’s the truth: real confidence isn’t found in thinking more - it’s found in learning to trust yourself, think better, and act with clarity. And yes, it is totally possible to train your brain to stop running mental marathons that lead absolutely nowhere.

In the words that follow, I’m going to show you exactly why we get stuck in the loop, how it’s messing with your confidence, and - most importantly - how to finally quiet that inner noise so you can move forward with power, peace, and purpose.

So grab a cuppa, breathe out that brain fog, and let’s break the habit of overthinking once and for all.

let’s break the habit of overthinking once and for all.


What Overthinking Really Is

(And Why It’s Not Helping)

Okay, here’s the not-so-fun truth: overthinking feels productive… but it’s really just fear in disguise wearing a lab coat and holding a clipboard.


You think you’re being thorough. You think you’re preparing for all the possibilities.


But what you’re really doing is running in mental circles, rehearsing worst-case scenarios, and creating problems that don’t exist - all because your brain is trying to keep you “safe.”


See, overthinking is your mind’s way of saying:

If I can just think through every possible outcome, I won’t be caught off guard. I won’t fail. I won’t get hurt.


But here’s the kicker: the longer you stay stuck in your head, the more disconnected you become from your intuition, your confidence, and your ability to act. You end up second-guessing everything, delaying progress, and feeding your inner doubt monster a five-course meal every day.


Overthinking isn’t protection - it’s procrastination wrapped in anxiety.


Coversations

Where Overthinking Comes From

(Hint: It’s Not Because You’re Broken)

Let me just say this loud and clear: You’re not “bad” at making decisions. You’re not weak. You’re just human - with a conditioned mind.


Most people who struggle with overthinking were taught somewhere along the line that:

Sound familiar?


This kind of mental programming creates fear of failure, rejection, embarrassment… or even success. And so your mind goes into overdrive, trying to analyze every tiny step to avoid the risk of being “wrong.”


The good news? You can rewire that.


Just like you were taught to overthink, you can learn to unlearn it. (More on that coming up. I’ve got you.)


The good news? You can rewire that.


Meet Ella: The Ambitious Nail-Biting Overthinker

Let’s take a little detour and meet Ella.


Ella works in a fast-paced office - the kind with never-ending emails, back-to-back meetings, and a coffee machine that somehow knows exactly when not to work.


She’s smart, driven, and ready to move up the ladder. She knows her stuff - but she also knows that to really get noticed and be taken seriously, she’s got to level up how she presents herself, too.


There’s just one thing… well, two, actually.


First: She bites her nails. Badly.
We’re talking down to the quick, hiding her hands in meetings, feeling self-conscious during handshakes kind of badly.


Second: She overthinks everything.
Every email, every presentation, every moment of silence in a conversation - her mind races through every possible outcome like she’s trying to win gold at the Anxiety Olympics.


One day, while staring down at her chewed nails (again), it hit her:

“I’m not just biting my nails. I’m thinking myself into worry. The nail-biting is just a symptom of what’s really going on.”


Boom. Lightbulb moment.


She realized that if she wanted to move forward in her career and feel confident doing it, she had to deal with the real problem: the overthinking loop that had been running in the background for years.


So what did she do?


She talked to a coach - someone who helped her untangle the mental spaghetti, spot the thought patterns that were messing with her confidence, and rewire the beliefs that were feeding her fear.


Fast forward a few weeks? Ella’s nails were healing, her inner critic was quieting down, and she was finally showing up at work like the leader she knew she was all along.


No magic. Just a mindset shift.


Mindset Change


From Awareness to Action

Now, you might not work in a bustling office or bite your nails like Ella (or maybe you do - no judgment here), but one thing’s for sure:


Overthinking shows up differently for everyone - Sometimes it’s procrastination wrapped in perfectionism.


Other times, it’s sleepless nights replaying awkward conversations from 2007.


But just like Ella discovered, the moment you realize it’s not just a quirky habit or a personality trait - it’s a pattern - that’s when the magic starts.


Because if it’s a pattern, that means it can be broken.

And if it can be broken… it can be replaced.


So let’s get to it.


Because if it’s a pattern, that means it can be broken


5 Powerful Ways to Break the Habit of Overthinking

Here are some real, doable ways to break free from the overthinking habit and start creating mental space for clarity, confidence, and those goals you've been quietly shelving for “someday.”

1. Catch It in the Act


Before you can change a habit, you’ve got to spot it as it’s happening.


Overthinking is sneaky - it often disguises itself as “being prepared” or “caring too much.” Start asking yourself:


“Am I solving a problem, or am I just spinning in circles?”


Quick Tip: Keep a small notepad or use your phone’s notes app. Every time you catch yourself overthinking, jot it down. Awareness is step one. You can't change what you're not aware of!


2. Set a “Worry Window”


Sounds odd, I know - but give your worries a schedule. Let’s say you set aside 15 minutes in the evening as your official "worry time."


You’ll be surprised how often, by the time it rolls around, the thoughts don’t feel so urgent anymore.


Why it works: It trains your brain that you control the worry - not the other way around.


3. Shift From Thinking to Doing


Overthinking keeps us stuck in our heads. The fastest way out? Action. Even a tiny one.


Want to apply for a job? Send the email.
Thinking of starting a business? Sketch the idea.
Worried someone’s mad at you? Ask them directly.


Progress happens when your feet move, not when your brain loops.


4. Talk It Out (Yes, Even With Yourself)


There’s nothing wrong with having a good ol’ chat - even if it's in the mirror. But bonus points if you speak to someone who can help you reframe things, like a coach or someone who gets it.


Say it with me: Is this thought helpful or hurtful?”

If it’s hurtful - challenge it. Don't let it move in rent-free.


5. Practice Mental Boundaries


Just like you wouldn’t let someone walk into your home with muddy shoes, don’t let every thought trample through your peace.


Set boundaries with your own mind. When a thought starts looping like a bad 90s remix, say:


“Nope. We’re not doing this today.”


And then redirect your focus - breathe, stretch, go outside, listen to your favourite playlist. Train your mind like a muscle.


Final Thoughts: You Don’t Have to Do It Alone

Overthinking isn’t a personality flaw - it’s a habit. A well-worn groove in your mind that’s been rehearsed over and over again. But like any habit, it can be unlearned. You can rewire your thoughts. You can feel peace in the middle of a storm. And yes - you can absolutely stop biting your nails too (just ask our office heroine).


You’ve already taken the first step just by being here, reading this. That means you’re curious, ready, and oh-so-close to real change.


But sometimes, the missing link between understanding and transformation is having someone help you apply the tools in your world, your thoughts, and your reality. That’s where I come in and work with you.


Let me show you how to go even deeper and make overthinking a thing of the past - not just for a day, but for life.


Don’t ever give up on your dreams

-Carl.


Let’s Make a Change Together:

First, thank you for being here. I know how tough it can be to navigate life’s challenges alone. But here’s the thing - you don’t have to. That’s exactly why I do what I do: to help you move past the roadblocks and step into the life you truly want and deserve.


Your Free Strategy Session

If anything you’ve read here on this site has resonated with you - whether it’s a new perspective or just a small glimmer of hope - I’d love to continue the conversation. That’s why I’m offering a FREE strategy session where we’ll dive into your challenges and uncover real solutions tailored to you. This isn’t just a casual chat - it’s a chance to gain clarity, discover actionable steps, and start shifting your mindset in a meaningful way.


Why Book a Call?

Get Clarity - Identify what’s been holding you back.

Find Solutions - Learn simple, actionable steps to move forward.

Gain Momentum - Start making real changes in your life today.

Many people stay stuck, believing they’ll figure things out alone. But that only leads to the same frustrating patterns. This is your opportunity to break free.


How to Book

Click the link, pick a time that works for you, and you’re in! I keep my availability flexible, but spots fill up fast - so don’t wait.


What Happens if You Don’t Book?

Nothing changes. The same challenges, frustrations, and self-doubt will still be there tomorrow. But if you take action today, you’re choosing to invest in your future self.


This is your time. Let’s get you moving in the right direction. Book your FREE strategy session now and take the first step toward lasting change!

© Copyright 2025 Created by Carl Dunn - Mindset Mind Coaching. All Rights Reserved.